Clearing the Pathways - Sonia Moore Interviews Judy McMurtry
Updated: Nov 13

Clearing the Pathway – Judy McMurtry Helps Businesses Rediscover Their Way
By Sonia Moore
The Business Background
Meeting Judy McMurtry was a fascinating moment for Sytuate. Often, we claim that people who have worked in every position know the most about a business. In the airline industry, she’s that person.
In her own words, fixing and flying were the only jobs she’s never touched. Everything else, ranging from bookings to boardrooms, has come under her remit at one point or another, giving her that rare business skill or not simply diagnosing a problem, but knowing how to fix it too.
Her last operational role was the masterpiece that proved she was at the top of her game. She was appointed to lead Delta Air Lines’ underperforming operation in Philadelphia. It was ranked 19th out of 21 based on its category for Delta Air Lines' Airport Operations, in a hub owned by American Airlines.
Under her direction and at a breakneck speed of under six months, it was ranked first.
Anyone who knows the business will tell you that businesses often don’t achieve such marked turnarounds, and when they do it’s more like eighteen to twenty-four months. Delta Air Lines' Philadelphia Airport Operations remained among the top five in its internal category for more than six years.
Not one to rest on her laurels, Judy went on to lead the airport’s airline managers council, helping join up airlines and government bodies over the next three years. A position in leadership that led to a realisation that she had the skills and authority to make a difference to wider business.
Forming Her Own Approach
COVID struck and Judy decided to retire from the corporate world, and like many others follow a more personal and purposeful direction. Using her hard-won experience to start JM Excel Consultants, repackaging her knowledge for a wider market. Her initial focus was on both businesses struggling to regain their momentum and those that had reached a plateau.
Her method is the same in both cases. A diagnosis is formed as with all consultancies. The individual expertise is how this problem appears in middle management and works its way into frontline teams. Blockers are identified and implementation is formed.
Profit is the last link in the chain. In her opinion, it’s the result of alignment between people, processes and performance. Get this right on the ground level and the money is the result. Start with an overly commercial focus and these key factors will slip out of sync and ultimately impact the bottom line.
That's why, when you ask her what her real skill is, she doesn't talk about frameworks. She talks about listening. ‘People have to know, like, and trust you before they buy into whatever you're going to do," she says. ‘Clear communication starts with listening. That way I can ask the right questions and really find out information.’
Winning People Back
In businesses that have lost their way and need turning round, strategy is normally not the issue. It’s deeper than that. People have stopped believing that anything will change. How does Judy propose you pull them back – especially after trust has been eroded?
Judy told us she has a three-pronged approach. It starts by inviting them into the process. Next, it’s vital to demonstrate your operational acumen to demonstrate competency. ‘You have to at least show them quickly that you’re not that person who just makes promises you’re not going keep.”
Finally, it’s about hearing what you’re being told by the people in the job roles. ‘They’re the ones dealing with the real difficulties every day. No one understands the issues quite as well as they do. And often, they also know the solutions.’
It’s a philosophy that she extends to managers, bringing middle management into the work to learn by example and leaving skills that continue to make a difference after her appointment is finished. She says that it’s also the emotive cues that we read unconsciously that breaks down walls.
People know if you respect them from how you talk to them and treat them. ‘You can pretty much feel when someone really doesn’t want to be bothered. Body language and gut feelings really can tell you a lot’
Different Day, Same Problems
According to Judy, the issue that dominates most struggling business is an insistence on top-down control. Leaders can become convinced that they hold all the answers, and in the worst cases, may be trying to demonstrate proficiency by making themselves pivotal in every decision, when in fact they should be processing the information from the frontline.
In a picture many people in HR will have seen before, employees are promoted based on competency and then often abandoned when it comes to informing them on how to navigate leadership duties. Judy even tells us that when businesses manage to train effectively, they still often allow knowledge to concentrate in one individual who is super skilled at communication and delegation. This carries its own risk; as when they leave all that organisational intelligence walks out the door with them.
This issue is getting sharper. ‘Now AI is a factor for so many businesses, it’s harder for them to implement an automated process if they can’t describe or define the original process. If nothing is written down or mapped – then you can’t rely on an AI to create documentation that’s unique to your business from generally available thinking.’
Remembering the Climb
With so many leaders coming up through the ranks, we asked Judy why many of them forgot what it was like to struggle on the way up – and had issues communicating the wider life breakthroughs that allowed them to become effective?
‘The good ones remember well;’ Judy says. Leaders who genuinely respect people never forget the climb. The others forget because they’re too busy controlling their image. ‘It’s about me now’, she says, illustrating the mindset. ‘Even though others helped you there, you never accomplish anything on your own.’
Underneath it, she muses, is probably fear. The higher you climb, the fewer people you can trust. New leaders often believe that they can’t go back to their team for answer. ‘I’m the boss now, and having to ask would look like weakness’ – she tells us. They try to work it out alone, under even more pressure and often without any training or preparation for the role. ‘They’d go further if they went back to the people and listened to what they have to say.’
The best way, she claims, is to simply get people to reveal their vision through effective questioning. ‘How did you get this role? What was your journey?’ Through coaching questions, she draws out the leader’s vision and then helps them align it with the wider goals of the company and the wants of the workforce. “They really get it when they pull the two together’
Big Picture Vision
The alignment she creates depends on a shared understanding of their purpose. Something Judy believes that many businesses have unconsciously lost – because they didn’t know its value.
Companies don’t need to rediscover their vision, she asserts. Most of them were unaware that such a narrative existed in the first place, or they lost sight of it during growth phases where it seemed unimportant and those processes, people and performance we mentioned earlier all lined up. ‘There comes a point where the majority of employees have no clue where they might find the mission or vision of the business, let alone what it might mean to them.’ And yet it’s the unifying factor that should tether all KPIs and systems to the same place. Without it teams withdraw into silos and start to move in their own directions.
As with so many things in business, the fix is to involve middle managers in strategic planning. They should be able to participate in creating it rather than just seeing the end results. Organisations assume these people can’t handle strategy. Judy disagrees 'You're still whiteboarding with them. They understand, and they can give you a better view of how that mission and the execution work.’ Their loyalty is both to the company and the customers they serve, which often gives them a better perspective on the effectiveness of a hypothetical approach.
Judy breaks apart the silos with this framework. Where we are now. Where do we want to be? How do we get there? She builds the answers with the company, rather than simply telling them the answer. ‘Everything is done for with them – you have to guide them like a coach would.’
A Perfect Storm
Judy believes there are three big issues facing businesses right now. The first is a generational shift. Older workers are leaving and younger hires having different expectations around workplace culture; working from home, flexibility, mental health breaks and communication styles.
The second is AI. Tools that are supposed to make jobs more efficient are still unproven in the workplace. Many places lack policies and guidelines on how to use AI, and whilst it can produce work at pace, often it takes comparable amounts of time to check and correct its output.
Finally, she returns to the issues of silos, which is in part caused by the working styles of the new generation and whilst is not attributable to AI, is certainly in part down to the rise of technology. ‘After COVID, no one addressed the issues of silos. People became isolated and even when we opened up, there’s still the option to avoid contact. You cannot operate a business this way’
The threat is that we lose the human connections and innovation that happens in the casual space. That businesses lose the magic of relationships, where moments of shared emotion have the space to flower through playful exchanges. Where a half joking idea turns into the seed of a new process or a way of thinking.
Work has lost these water cooler moments and doesn’t currently have a plan for getting them back. Younger employees are often well-versed in navigating complex tools but feel anxious when approached with the spontaneity of conversation.
The Final Word
Judy’s advice for leaders is both simple and stark. You have probably heard it before.
‘Stop working in the business and start working on it.’
When you are buried in the everyday activities, you cannot see what’s working and what isn’t – everything turns into a to-do list, and you focus on completing individual items. You’re there to make sure they all link up, and others should be telling you whether the plans you put in place are working. Trust those outside eyes to see what you can’t.
Her closing message goes beyond any one company. ‘We’re in a perfect storm,’ she says. Getting through it, and coming out the other side well, depends on one thing she thinks we’ve lost: unity. That means communication, community, and respect for each other’s differences.
“We’re all different, and that’s good. I can learn from you and you from me;” she says. “No one is so special they are indispensable, and together we can go so much further.”



Comments